15 High-Concept Movies That Sounded Awesome but Wasted Their Potential

Don’t you hate it when you hear a film premise that blows you away, only for the film to squander that premise?

We often recommend media and products we like. If you buy anything through links on our site, we may earn a commission.

Is there anything more disappointing than a movie whose premise sounds amazing, only for it to be so poorly executed that you can’t help but be angry?

It pains me when a writer or director has a golden egg in their hands and then breaks it into a million pieces—not only because their film sucks, but because it taints all future attempts at a similar premise.

To be fair, a “wasted potential” movie can still be an enjoyable movie to watch, but you’ll always have that nagging feeling of “What if?” at the back of your mind. What if it had been done well? How much better could this experience be? Argh!

This article won’t have ANY spoilers. I’ll just describe each film’s premise and couple it with the film’s trailer so that you, too, can have your hopes raised and then dashed when you get around to watching it.

1. King Arthur: Legend of the Sword

A stylish epic fantasy re-imagination of the story of King Arthur, complete with warlocks and demons and mythical war elephants.

2. The Discovery

The afterlife is scientifically and empirically proven to be real, which has led to an incredibly high suicide rate across the world.

3. Bright

In a fantasy alternate universe where Los Angeles has become home to humans, fairies, elves, and even orcs, a human LAPD police office and his orc partner begrudgingly work together to protect a magic wand with unspoken power.

4. Circle

Fifty people wake up in a dark room. Every two minutes, one of them is killed. If anyone tries to leave, they’re killed. And eventually they figure out that they can control who dies next.

5. Vantage Point

An attempt is made on the President of the United States’s life. This single event is told from the perspective of various characters.

6. The Invention of Lying

In the entire world, nobody has ever told a lie. However, one man discovers how to tell a lie, and he’s the only one who can.

7. Sunshine

The sun is on the verge of dying, so a group of astronauts embark on a mission to reignite it. However, they aren’t the first group to have tried it: the previous mission team from seven years ago mysteriously vanished.

8. Jumper

A young man, several years after discovering that he has the ability to teleport, is hunted down by a secret organization.

9. Push

A group with superhuman abilities joins forces to take down a government conspiracy.

10. Hancock

An alcoholic vigilante with superhuman powers and a bad attitude wants to be a hero but causes more problems than he solves.

11. Plus One

Shudder is an streaming service with thousands of horror, thriller, and suspense movies. It’s an excellent value for fans of thrills. Try it FREE for 7 days!

During a college party, a mysterious event causes the emergence of sinister doppelgangers, which throws everything into chaos and danger.

12. Timer

In the near future, people can be implanted with a timer that counts down to the day when they meet their soulmate. However, one woman’s timer is blank.

13. In Time

In the near future, everyone stops aging at 25 and has only one year left to live. However, one’s remaining time can be transferred to others, leading to time being used as currency.

14. War of the Worlds

A father struggles to keep his two children safe and alive when monstrous aliens invade Earth and begin to wipe out entire cities.

15. Sphere

When a 300-year-old alien spacecraft is discovered deep in the Pacific Ocean, a team of scientists and experts venture down to make sense of it.

30 Days of Modern Geeky Movies

Are you bored and in need of movies to watch? Here at whatNerd, we’ve seen a lot of geeky movies—sci-fi movies, fantasy movies, thriller movies, you name it!

And while a lot of them were pretty forgettable, a few of them stand out as classic geeky movies that everyone should definitely watch. Check out our 30 favorite modern geeky movies.

All of these movies are from 2000 or later, and there are NO superhero movies on our list! Download the printable PDF below and see how many you can watch in the next 30 days:

Similar & Trending

The 15 Most Rewatchable Movies Worth Watching Again and Again

The 8 Most Profound Character Deaths in Sci-Fi Movies

The 12 Best Fantasy Worlds and Magical Realms in Movies, Ranked

Why “Batman Returns” Is Still the Best Batman Movie: 5 Reasons

The 8 Most Evil Robots and Machines in Movie History, Ranked

The 15 Best Movie Franchises, Ranked (And Why They’re Great)

Cinema’s Silent Era, Explained (And 4 Must-Watch Silent Films)

How Action Movies Changed in the 21st Century: 4 Ways

12 Incredible Improv Movies That Started Without Scripts